File #: 22-G-062    Version: Name:
Type: Item of Discussion Status: Recommended Motion (Section I)
File created: 3/15/2022 In control: City Council
On agenda: 3/28/2022 Final action: 3/28/2022
Title: HEART BARRIE LANDMARK SIGN AMENDMENT #1 Moved by: Councillor, K. Aylwin Seconded by: Councillor, C. Riepma That motion 22-G-062 of Section "I" of the General Committee Report dated March 21, 2022 be referred to a future General Committee meeting and that staff provide a memorandum with the following information in advance of that meeting: a. The full costs associated with terminating the contract for the Heart Barrie Sign project, b. The full costs incurred to date by the City of Barrie for the Heart Barrie Sign project, c. A process to provide the funding received for the signage back to the appropriate donors. A point of order was raised by Councillor, G. Harvey. Councillor Harvey questioned the reference of a media article by the mover of the motion. Mayor J. Lehman ruled that a referral motion is not debatable. A point of order was raised by Councillor, R. Thomson. Councillor Thomson questioned the procedure of referring the motion to increase the size of the heart in the Hea...

Title

HEART BARRIE LANDMARK SIGN

 

AMENDMENT #1

 

Moved by:                     Councillor, K. Aylwin

Seconded by:                     Councillor, C. Riepma

 

That motion 22-G-062 of Section “I” of the General Committee Report dated March 21, 2022 be referred to a future General Committee meeting and that staff provide a memorandum with the following information in advance of that meeting:

 

a.                     The full costs associated with terminating the contract for the Heart Barrie Sign project,

b.                     The full costs incurred to date by the City of Barrie for the Heart Barrie Sign project,

c.                     A process to provide the funding received for the signage back to the appropriate donors.

 

A point of order was raised by Councillor, G. Harvey. Councillor Harvey questioned the reference of a media article by the mover of the motion. Mayor J. Lehman ruled that a referral motion is not debatable.

 

A point of order was raised by Councillor, R. Thomson. Councillor Thomson questioned the procedure of referring the motion to increase the size of the heart in the Heart Barrie Landmark Sign back to General Committee. Mayor J. Lehman clarified that the motion is on the Heart Barrie Landmark Sign project and is requesting further information. Mayor Lehman ruled that the motion is in order.

 

A point of order was raised by Councillor, K. Aylwin. Councillor Aylwin questioned if the motion could be a deferral motion so that it may be debated by Council. Mayor, J. Lehman clarified that a referral motion is the proper mechanism to get the item back to General Committee with the requested information.

 

The recorded vote was taken as follows:

 

 

Yes: 4 -                     Mayor, J. Lehman

                                                               Councillor, C. Riepma

                                                               Councillor, K. Alywin

                                                               Cuoncillor, A.M. Kungl

 

No: 7 -                                          Deputy Mayor, B. Ward

                                                               Councillor, R. Thomson

                                                               Councillor, N. Harris

                                                               Councillor, G. Harvey

                                                               Councillor, J. Harris

                                                               Councillor, S. Morales

                                                               Councillor, M. McCann

 

LOST

 

AMENDMENT #2

 

Moved by:                                          Councillor, K. Aylwin

Seconded by:                     Councillor, C. Riepma

 

That motion 22-G-062 of Section “I” of the General Committee Report dated March 21, 2022 be amended by adding the following paragraph:

 

“2.                     That Councillor McCann provide a list of donors to the Heart Barrie Company to the City and that staff in Access Barrie publish this list on the City’s Heart Barrie sign webpage.”

 

CARRIED

 

A point of order was raised by Councillor, M. McCann on the basis that he took exception to the use of the words “funneling of funds”. Mayor J. Lehman overruled the point of order.

 

Upon the question of the original motion moved by Deputy Mayor, B. Ward and seconded by Councillor, R. Thomson, the motion was CARRIED AS AMENDED BY AMENDMENT #2. (Item for Discussion 8.6, March 21, 2022)